Direct naar de inhoud
BuiltInEu

Zoeken

Menu

Policy Digest

Italy fines Meta €805m over Facebook's Android gallery access

Published How we checked

Built in EU policy cover card. Headline: Italy fines Meta €805m over Facebook's Android gallery access

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta €805m (about $887m) over how the Facebook app for Android reached into users' photo galleries. The Next Web and Politico EU both reported the decision on 14 November 2026. The Garante said the app pulled photos, videos and their metadata without specific consent or proper notice. It put the number of affected Android users in Italy at about 20 million.

The feature in question proposes gallery photos and videos for new posts. Politico EU describes it as Facebook's camera roll suggestions, and The Next Web says it has been available since 2023. Reuters was first to report the decision in English, according to The Next Web.

What did the Garante actually object to?

The finding is about permission design, not about the photos themselves. Facebook asked for gallery access through one permission that covered the whole app. According to the authority, a generic warning came before that request, so users had no way of knowing they were switching on suggestions. The Garante also said such a permission can let the app read a phone's entire photo archive, usually for good.

The investigation began in 2025. The legal basis was Article 122 of the Italian privacy code, under which a phone counts as part of its owner's private sphere. In setting the amount, the regulator considered a 2019 decision against Meta and what it called poor cooperation.

The remedies matter more to buyers than the headline figure. Meta has 60 days to collect separate, specific consent for the feature and to explain how it can be switched off. The feature must also stay off by default, even for people who already said yes. In our reading, that last order is the expensive one: consent gathered through a broad prompt does not carry forward.

For scale, The Next Web puts the fine at about 0.47% of Meta's global turnover. That sits near the €825m Dutch fine on Uber, and below Meta's €1.2bn GDPR fine over data transfers. Meta did not immediately comment and has the right to appeal, Politico EU reported.

The probe has limits. AI training sat outside its scope, so investigators never tested whether gallery material fed Meta's models, a use Meta disputes. The Garante will review a cloud processing feature, launched in 2026, as a separate matter.

Why couldn't Meta send this to Dublin?

Meta argued the Irish regulator should handle the case. The Garante refused, because it acted under ePrivacy rules, and ePrivacy has no one-stop-shop mechanism. This is the part of the decision with the longest tail.

Our reading is that a US vendor's standing with the Irish regulator says little about its exposure on device access. A national authority enforcing its own ePrivacy law did not need to wait for Ireland here. For anyone scoring vendor risk on mobile apps, that means checking each app's permission behaviour, not just its GDPR paperwork.

It also widens the touchpoint. The question is no longer only where a vendor stores data, but what its app can read on a phone your staff carry.

What should IT and compliance teams do this quarter?

We hold that a closing passage should name a role, a timeframe and an action. Here there are two.

Product owners who ship an Android app should find any feature that rides on a single app-wide permission behind a vague pre-prompt. The Garante has now priced that pattern, and its remedy (feature-level consent, default off, existing users reset) is a usable specification for a fix.

Organisations weighing whether to keep an official presence on Facebook can look at Mastodon, which our feature audit records as verified open source and self-hostable. Self-hosting controls where posts live, though it does not by itself settle what any phone app can read.

Before this quarter closes, the mobile device management lead should pull a permissions report for managed Android phones and flag every app holding full gallery access. Compliance should then re-score those vendors on device access, because Italy has shown a national regulator can act without going through Dublin.

Sources

Share this article

Share on X

Products Mentioned

Ready to Switch to European Alternatives?

Explore our directory of 400+ European alternatives to US tech products.

Browse Categories